In 2004, the California legislature passed a bill that tightened the participation requirement for California's welfare program, the California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids Program (CalWORKs) and mandated a study of CalWORKs sanction policy for participant noncompliance in the welfare-to-work program. RAND was asked by the California Department of Social Services to carry out this study. Findings show that county welfare caseworkers' implementation of the state's statutory sanction policy makes the sanctions weaker in practice than might have been expected given stated policy. Both caseworkers and higher-level county welfare department employees are strongly reluctant to sanction clients. Furthermore, caseworkers perceive the statutory noncompliance process to be burdensome. Implementation of sanction policy varies widely across California's 58 counties. RAND researchers note three possible directions for reforming California's sanction policy and practice: (1) swifter sanctions, (2) stronger sanctions with greater financial penalties, and (3) safer sanctions, to ensure that clients are not inappropriately sanctioned due to some combination of caseworker error, lack
of knowledge of how to remedy the sanction, or the existence of undisclosed serious barriers.