This issue of Global Health Nexus takes a look
at the juncture we have reached in the dental profession's
ongoing debate regarding access to dental care, and, in
particular, whether the rapidly accelerating
initiative—known as the dental therapist or midlevel
provider movement—will actually expand access to care.
Not long ago, I was invited to give a talk celebrating
the 200th anniversary of the Massachusetts General
Hospital, and I used the midlevel provider movement in
dentistry to explore the broader societal trends affecting
the profession—including economics, demographics, public
relations, and public policy. By tracking the trends from
1947 to the present and then overlaying them, some of the
findings that emerged were rather remarkable and explained
a lot, including the traction being gained by the dental
therapist movement.
These findings spurred me to write the article, "What Just
Happened?," which immediately follows this message. In
that article, I offer both an overview of the reasons
underlying state and national interest in implementing
training programs for midlevel providers and a discussion
of my personal concerns and skepticism about the ultimate
effectiveness of this approach in expanding access to care
for the people who need it most.
Mine is one of several perspectives on the debate
included in this issue of Global Health Nexus,
which also offers opinions from several leading advocates
for, and opponents of, the dental therapist movement. They
are Dr. Raymond F. Gist, president of the American Dental
Association (ADA); Dr. Carter Brown, a private practice
general dentist who is also a South Carolina state dental
society leader; Ann Battrell, RDH, MSDH, executive director
of the American Dental Hygienists' Association; and Dr.
David A. Nash, William R. Willard Professor of Dental
Education and professor of pediatric dentistry at the
University of Kentucky College of Dentistry. Rounding out
the discussion are comments by NYUCD's Dr. Ananda
Dasanayake, who was commissioned by the California Dental
Association to conduct a systematic review entitled "Are Dental
Procedures Performed by Auxiliaries Safe and of Comparable
Quality?"; and by NYUCD's national and international
outreach leadership team, on "The Role of Dental
Schools in Expanding Access to Oral Health Care."
The University as a Conversation
Someone once described a university as an ongoing
conversation—one with hundreds of people at any given time
that goes on for years, and decades, even for centuries.
People join the conversation and people depart from it, but
the conversation continues. At first glance, a conversation
seems like a pretty flimsy foundation on which to build a
major institution-but nothing could be further from the
truth. The intellectual engagement fostered by dialogue and
debate as well as the ideas it inspires is far stronger
than bricks and mortar. The power inherent in this
definition of a university is evident in the antiquity of
some universities—among the oldest institutions in the
world. Thirty-nine continuously operating universities were
founded before 1500 and even here in the United States
there are universities with buildings older than the
country they are located in. NYU—and its College of
Dentistry—identify strongly with that tradition. We are
committed to the role of a research university as a forum
for discussion and inclusion of various viewpoints; or, to
put it another way, to the role of a research university as
a counterforce to dogmatism. Indeed, as NYU President John
Sexton has written: "The embrace of the contest of ideas
and tolerance of criticism does not mean a surrender of
conviction. Dialogue within the university is characterized
by a commitment to engage and even invite, through reasoned
discourse, the most powerful challenges to one's point of
view. This requires attentiveness and mutual respect,
accepting what is well founded in the criticisms offered by
others, and defending one's own position, where
appropriate, against them..."
It is within this context of listening to the views of
others that I want to assert that the dentist is the gold
standard in delivering oral health care, for it is the
dentist who brings to patient care a breadth of education
and knowledge that is designed to provide higher-level
treatment outcomes than those who have been trained purely
as technicians. However, this belief does not preclude
careful attention to the points of view of others who are
striving with the best intentions to fix a system in which
too many people are not receiving the dental care they
need.
Other articles in this issue that I believe will also
engage your interest concern innovative research, much of
it collaborative, that is being conducted at NYUCD in the
areas of bone biology, oral cancer pain, evolution theory,
gene therapy and engineering, and the links between
periodontal disease and diabetes. Regarding collaboration,
I especially want to turn your attention to the opening
story in News from the Colleges entitled "Groundbreaking
Surgery Merges Passion, Computer Technology, and
Teamwork," which features a pioneering procedure using
virtual surgery-performed by NYUCD alumnus, oral and
maxillofacial and head and neck surgeon Dr. David Hirsch,
in collaboration with NYU physician Dr. Jamie Levine and
Dr. Larry Brecht, a maxillofacial prosthodontist, and also
an NYUCD alumnus-to save the life of a young woman with a
large tumor in her left jaw.
You will also meet other outstanding faculty, as well as
students and staff, who are contributing on many levels to
NYUCD's increasingly diverse and robust academic
environment, as well as learn about the exciting ongoing
philanthropic support and international activities that are
helping us to aspire to ever-higher levels of
excellence.
Also in this issue, you will read about one of the great
milestones of the academic year—the annual celebratory rite
of passage of graduation day. It is a day that reminds us
all of our reason for being and brings us back to the theme
of this issue of Global Health Nexus: Devising
ways to help improve the health of our society.