New York University Skip to Content Skip to Search Skip to Navigation Skip to Sub Navigation

NYU School of Law's Center On the Administration of Criminal Law Files Amicus Brief in Blackwater Case

January 28, 2009
N-255, 2008-09

New York University School of Law’s Center on the Administration of Criminal Law filed an amicus curiae brief yesterday in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia. The brief supports the U.S. government’s prosecution of five former Blackwater Worldwide security guards who are charged with voluntary manslaughter and other crimes stemming from their involvement in a 2007 shooting incident in a Baghdad square in which they are accused of killing 14 unarmed civilians.

The brief disputes the defendants’ argument that the relevant version of the Military Extraterritorial Jurisdiction Act (MEJA) does not apply to them. MEJA confers federal jurisdiction over contractors of any federal agency who commit serious crimes overseas to the extent their employment relates to supporting the mission of the Department of Defense overseas. Defendants contend that they are not covered by this statute and cannot be prosecuted for any crimes they allegedly committed because they were employed by the Department of State, which they say has its own distinct mission.

“The case presents an important issue of first impression regarding the scope of federal prosecutors’ extra-territorial power over private contractors who operate abroad in war zones,” said Anthony Barkow, who is the center’s executive director and who was a federal prosecutor for 12 years. “Congress intended private contractors who commit crimes while supporting the mission of the Department of Defense to be subject to United States criminal jurisdiction. The center seeks to preserve the government’s ability to exercise its prosecutorial power to the full extent contemplated and permitted by Congress in this context.”

The amicus brief argues that it cannot be seriously disputed that the mission of the U.S. military in Iraq is to establish and maintain a secure environment and to promote relief and reconstruction efforts and that defendants were employed to support this mission by protecting U.S. embassy personnel, who themselves advance the U.S. military mission in Iraq. Further, MEJA’s enactment and legislative history confirm Congress’ intent to confer jurisdiction over contractors like defendants. According to the brief, there is no possibility that defendants were surprised to learn that firing upon and killing unarmed civilians is potentially criminal and that they could be prosecuted in U.S. courts when they were immune from prosecution in Iraqi courts, and thus they had sufficient advance notice that they would be prosecuted for such conduct.

The brief is the first the center has filed on behalf of the government. The center’s litigation practice concentrates on cases in which the exercise of prosecutorial discretion raises significant substantive legal issues. In addition to filing briefs on behalf of defendants when prosecutors act over-aggressively, the center also defends exercises of prosecutorial or governmental discretion from unfounded criticism, when appropriate, where the discretionary decisions comported with applicable law and standard practices and are consistent with law enforcement priorities.

Barkow prepared the brief in partnership with the law firm of Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld.

Reporter Contact: Anthony Barkow
Executive Director, Center on the Administration of Criminal Law NYU School of Law
212.998.6612
anthony.barkow@nyu.edu
www.prosecutioncenter.org

        

EDITORS NOTE
The Center on the Administration of Criminal Law at New York University School of Law is an apolitical organization dedicated to defining good government practices in criminal prosecutions through academic research, litigation, and participation in the formulation of public policy. The Center is committed to identifying the best prosecutorial practices and suggesting avenues of reform. The Center’s litigation practice aims to use its empirical research and experience with criminal justice to assist in important criminal justice cases at all levels, concentrating on cases in which exercises of prosecutorial discretion raise significant substantive legal issues.

This Press Release is in the following Topics:
School of Law

Type: Press Release

Press Contact: Michael Orey | (914) 340-5555


Search News



NYU In the News

NYU Offers Financial Aid to Undocumented Students

The Wall Street Journal reported that NYU will begin offering scholarship aid to undocumented students for the school year beginning next September.

NYU Adopts Lean LaunchPad Program to Teach Entrepreneurship

Startup guru Steve Blank, in a Huffington Post blog, described how NYU adopted the Lean LaunchPad model to teach entrepreneurship to students and faculty at NYU.

Biology Professor Jane Carlton Examines Wastewater for the City’s Microbiome

The New York Times’ Science Times column “Well” profiled Biology Professor Jane Carlton and her research project to sequence microbiome of New York City by examining wastewater samples.

Steinhardt Professors Use a Play as Therapy

The New York Times wrote about a play written by Steinhardt Music Professor Robert Landy about the relationship between Adjunct Professor Cecilia Dintino, a clinical psychologist in the Drama Therapy Program, and a patient, former Broadway actress Jill Powell.

NYU Public Health Experts Urge Strengthening Local Health Systems to Combat Ebola

Dean Cheryl Healton of the Global Institute of Public Health and Public Health Professor Christopher Dickey wrote an op-ed in the Huffington Post saying international health agencies need to strengthen their presence in countries at the local level to prevent future ebola outbreaks.

NYU Footer